Home› Groups› Capacity Strengthening for Research› Capacity Strengthening for Research› Does intent matter more than impact?

Does intent matter more than impact?

Started by Rhoda Nakhosi Sep 8, 2026 10 replies 👁 8 views
Rhoda Nakhosi Admin Community Champion (1,500+ points) Community Champion
Sep 8, 2026 at 3:19 pm

If a study is published and no one outside of academia ever reads it, did it actually happen?

Fortunate Member Thought Leader (400+ points) Thought Leader
2 months ago

In academia, knowledge does not gain influence solely because it is rigorous. Who gets heard, whose research is visible, and where that research circulates also shapes what counts as knowledge. This is particularly important in African scholarship, where valuable local and community-based knowledge can remain marginalised when it is not visible within dominant academic and policy spaces

Rhoda Nakhosi Admin Community Champion (1,500+ points) Community Champion
↩ replied to Fortunate 2 months ago
Fortunate, this is spot on. Visibility is political, not neutral. And that leaves me with a tension: If the system is stacked against African scholarship, is "impact" even a fair measure to hold us to? But also knowing the system is broken, do we have a greater duty to find workarounds (open access, policy briefs, local languages), even when they don't count for promotion? Is naming the problem enough, or do we need to build the alternatives too?
Curious what meaningful impact looks like to you, beyond traditional metrics.
Silungile Member Contributor (50+ points) Contributor
↩ replied to Rhoda Nakhosi 2 months ago

I concur with you my dear visibility is political

Rhoda Nakhosi Admin Community Champion (1,500+ points) Community Champion
↩ replied to Silungile 2 months ago
@Silungile, you agreed that visibility is political. I would be curious how that plays out in your own context. The shape of marginalization differs by country and institution: some researchers are locked out by paywalls, others by language, others by the assumption that credible evidence must come from outside the continent. Which of those do you see most where you work? I ask because the workarounds we choose depend on which barrier is actually binding and I suspect we generalize too quickly from our own settings.
Desmond Angira Admin Community Champion (1,500+ points) Community Champion
2 months ago

I think it did—but its impact may not have travelled beyond academia.

Publishing is only one part of the research journey. If findings never reach policymakers, practitioners, communities, or the people who could actually use them, we may be missing a huge part of their value.

For me, the goal should be “publish and translate”—turning research into policy briefs, community-friendly content, presentations, media conversations, or practical tools.

Sometimes the question shouldn’t just be “Where will this be published?” but “Who needs to know this, and how do we make sure they can use it?”

Rhoda Nakhosi Admin Community Champion (1,500+ points) Community Champion
↩ replied to Desmond Angira 2 months ago

@Desmond Angira, "publish and translate" is the practical hinge, and I think it is the phrase most of us already believe in but rarely resource. The uncomfortable follow-up: translation is unpaid, unrecognized labour in most African institutions. It does not count for promotion. It is the first thing dropped when timelines tighten. So my question to you is whether you have seen a model where translation is built into the research budget and timelines from the start, not as an afterthought, but as a line item and a deliverable. If that exists somewhere, I would like to learn from it.

Dr. Magoba Member Expert (800+ points) Expert
2 months ago

Hi Rhoda, I think this question gets to the heart of why we do research in the first place.

For me, a study can certainly “happen” when it is published, but publication should be viewed as a milestone rather than the destination. A paper may be methodologically rigorous and contribute to the academic literature, yet its broader public health value remains limited if the evidence never reaches the people, programmes or decisions it was intended to inform.

I particularly appreciate Fortunate’s point about visibility and the structural barriers facing African scholarship. Impact should therefore not be judged only by citations, journal rankings, or whether research receives recognition within academic institutions. Those measures are useful, but they capture only a fraction of what research can achieve.

I would define meaningful impact more broadly as evidence creating a positive change in understanding, decisions, practice, policy, systems or people's lives.

Sometimes impact may be a national policy change or a programme being redesigned. At other times, it may be much smaller but equally meaningful: a health worker changing practice because of evidence, a community understanding an issue differently, a policymaker using local data to allocate resources, a programme identifying an underserved population, or young people using research findings to advocate for themselves.

This is why I strongly support the idea of “publish and translate.” Open access, policy briefs, stakeholder dialogues, community dissemination, local-language communication, dashboards, implementation tools and engagement with policymakers and practitioners can help research travel beyond the journal.

But I also think we need to go one step further: “publish, translate and track.” We should ask what happened after dissemination. Was the evidence considered? Was a programme modified? Did practice change? Did it influence resource allocation? Did communities benefit? If not, what prevented the evidence from being taken up?

From my perspective as an epidemiologist, the pathway should not end at:

Data → analysis → manuscript → publication.

It should ideally extend to:

Data → evidence → translation → engagement → decision → implementation → measurable change.

And perhaps this is where African researchers have an especially important opportunity. We should not wait for traditional academic systems to determine whether our work has value. We can build alternative pathways of visibility and impact that connect rigorous research with African policymakers, practitioners, communities and lived realities.

So, is naming the problem enough? I don't think so. Naming it is important because it makes structural barriers visible. But building alternatives—while simultaneously advocating for fairer systems—is where research can become genuinely transformative.

Ultimately, I would rather have a study that changes one important decision, improves one programme, strengthens one health system, or meaningfully improves people's lives than one that accumulates citations while remaining disconnected from the population it studied.

Research should not only be visible. It should be usable, accessible, accountable and capable of making a difference.

#ResearchImpact #AfricanScholarship #KnowledgeTranslation #OpenScience #PublicHealth

Rhoda Nakhosi Admin Community Champion (1,500+ points) Community Champion
↩ replied to Dr. Magoba 2 months ago

@Henry Magoba, your addition of "and track" is where I think most of us quietly fail. We disseminate and assume uptake. We rarely return to ask what changed. But tracking raises a hard question: who is accountable for it? If the answer is "the researcher, unpaid, after the grant has closed," then tracking will not happen at scale. Do you see a way to make tracking structural, built into funder requirements, institutional incentives, or partnership agreements rather than dependent on individual conscientiousness? Because your pathway from data to measurable change is right, but it needs an owner at every step.

Nonvicks Ochieng Member Community Champion (1,500+ points) Community Champion
2 months ago

@Rhoda Nakhosi Academically, the work is real the data was gathered, the methodology held up to peer review, and the findings are locked into the permanent scholarly record. But socially and practically, it exists in a vacuum. Research is meant to inform decisions, alter policy, or improve human conditions. When a paper sits unread behind a paywalled journal, written in dense jargon aimed solely at other academics, its real-world utility drops to zero. A study that never leaves the academic echo chamber achieves institutional recognition for the researcher, but it fails the communities and field teams who made the data collection possible in the first place.

Rhoda Nakhosi Admin Community Champion (1,500+ points) Community Champion
↩ replied to Nonvicks Ochieng 2 months ago

@Nonvicks, you put the sharpest point on it: the communities and field teams who made the data possible are often the last to see it. That is not just a failure of impact, it is a failure of accountability. And it raises something I have been circling: field teams are usually treated as data collectors, not as stakeholders in the findings. If we took your point seriously, what would it look like to report back to enumerators and communities as a standard step, not a courtesy? Have you seen that done well anywhere, or is it still the exception?